CATEGORY

COMMENTS*

Points

Preparation and Quality of Presentation

Presentation of the significant details of the clinical case

Spoke clearly and emphasized important points.

Adequate pace of delivery within required presentation length (~30 min)

Professionalism of presentation slides (i.e. no typos, grammatically correct, consistency and clarity formatting)

Answered and handled all questions appropriately in a confident manner.

       0-10 points

PICO

Question

Background search was conducted thoroughly and prior learning was reviewed and applied in developing the PICO question.

All PICO components are clearly defined, correctly written, and in the correct order.

The PICO question is appropriately derived from the case and reflects a clinically relevant question.

       0-10 points

Background on Topic/Biomedical

Able to thoroughly explain the events that occur at the physiological, and/or biochemical, cellular and molecular levels of the biomedical topic relevant to the case                  

Demonstrates a thorough understanding of how biomedical sciences/case topic apply to the clinical case

Demonstrates knowledge of pathology/disease implication on oral health and dental treatment                                                                                                                                                        

___0-15 points

Search and References

Description of the Key steps in the search strategy were completed;

1) key words and or MeSH terms were relevant to the PICO

2) PubMed or other EB search engines were used,

3) article retrieved from a peer-reviewed journal

4) article is of appropriate level of evidence and relevant to the PICO

5) References listed and formatted appropriately.

       0-5 points